THE INDIAN FIGHTER is a generally interesting 1955 pass at making a western with some depth, sympathetic to Native Americans (not that they get to play themselves) and with a novelistic-tinged approach in the writing by Ben Hecht that voices early environmental concerns, deals a bit with racism, throws in some daring-for-the-day sex, and thankfully has a battle at the tail end.
Produced by Kirk Douglas as a showcase starring vehicle for himself and to launch his own company, Bryna, it has intelligent dialogue, and most of the acting comes off fairly naturalistic under un-showy but stylish direction by Andre de Toth. Kirk’s ‘hero’ has some questionable behaviors. For one, he practically rapes the love interest, a Sioux maiden played by drop-dead stunner Elsa Martinelli, 20 and captivating, brought over from Italy on the strength of a magazine cover (she was a model) seen by Kirk’s wife Anne.
Now, Anne was Kirk’s 2nd wife. His first, Diana, co-stars here as secondary love-interest (thanks a load, baby). Meanwhile, Kirk, according to his memoirs, goes at it hot & heavy with Elsa. This is not hard to understand: one look at her here, bathing in a stream, when I first saw this a kid, pretty much helped cement my partner inclinations (along with Sophia Loren in The Pride And The Passion, so better or worse, I owe Italy a lot).
Walter Matthau is the bad guy—he debuted the same year, also playing a snake, in Burt Lancaster’s The Kentuckian. Others on board include Walter Abel, a noticeably booze-battered Lon Chaney Jr., Elisha Cook, Alan Hale Jr., Ray Teal, Frank Cady, William Phipps and Hank Worden. ‘Red Cloud’ is played, with stone-faced ‘dignity’ by Eduard Franz, who also suggested noble Native Americans in Broken Lance and the same years White Feather.
Beautiful location work around Bend, Oregon aids considerably, though a countervailing credit is the way-overdone score from the usually fine Franz Waxman. Attempting something important-symphonic ala Copland, it comes off blaring and obvious, cutesy and intrusive. Art directors provided a great fort. Directing, de Toth went off the usual cliché warpath and gave the Sioux credit for some smart tactics during the battle scene, confounding the white-eyes, not merely riding by as target practice.
One of his fifteen westerns, Kirk’s saga as ‘Johnny Hawks’ did a decent $2,550,000, and his marriage to Anne survived his dalliance with Elsa.




